The Renters' Rights Act 2025 (RRA) should not be abolished, but it should be amended, as Prosper UK is arguing. The principle of greater security for good tenants is widely accepted by responsible landlords.
The problem is how parts of the Act work in practice, and these need amending before they cause lasting damage to the private rented sector (PRS).
The main tenancy reforms under the RRA took effect in England on 1 May 2026, and landlords are now dealing with their real-world effects on rent increases, possession and costs. In Landbay's Q3 2026 survey of more than 2,000 landlords, 53% reported a negative impact from the Act on their buy-to-let business, and a third had decided to sell or were considering selling. In response, Prosper UK is calling on the government to amend the RRA and rule out rent controls.
There is an assumption that landlords who raise concerns about the Act are opposed to tenant security. This is not the case. Responsible landlords accept the principle, but many feel that parts of the Act are unworkable and risk driving out the very landlords who provide good-quality homes.
Closing the rent appeal loophole
Under the RRA, a tenant can challenge a rent increase at no risk to themselves, simply to delay paying a fair market rent, and the landlord bears the cost. Not only is this unfair, but it risks clogging up the tribunal and delaying genuine cases.
The Loophole Property tribunals made a record 166 market rent decisions in July 2026, nearly four times the number in July 2025, according to Hamptons. Since 1 May 2026, the tribunal can no longer set a rent higher than the landlord proposed, and an increase is not backdated when a challenge fails. A tenant therefore has nothing to lose by appealing, and the landlord absorbs the cost of the delay.
The government has committed to backdating rent for unsuccessful appeals, but only where the tribunal is judged to be "overwhelmed". That does not go far enough. Backdating every unsuccessful appeal to the date the increase would have started is common sense. It makes for a fairer process between landlords and tenants, discourages appeals made purely to delay, and protects a tribunal system that is already under strain.
The role of the tribunal
The tribunal's role is to determine the open market rent for the property under an assured periodic tenancy, not to decide what tenants can afford. So far, where tribunals have reduced rents, it has largely been because of the property's condition, which is a fair test. But if tribunals were to start weighing affordability over market evidence, they would move from assessing the market to regulating it. That would look like rent control by the back door and, over the long term, would push more landlords out.
Rule out rent controls
Uncertainty over rent controls is already making landlords think twice about staying in the sector, and many will not wait for a policy answer before deciding to sell.
The government can end this uncertainty with a single clear statement that rent controls are completely off the table. It would take no time, and would do more for rental supply than almost any other measure available. Landlords can plan around rules they do not like, but they cannot plan for rules that might change.
This links directly to the rent appeal issue. If the tribunal drifts from determining open market rents to effectively setting affordable ones, we will have rent control by the back door, and the effect on supply will be the same. Clarity on both would give landlords the confidence to stay and invest in their portfolios, and that is what tenants need most.
Why smaller landlords cannot be replaced
Build to Rent supports supply, but it cannot replace the individual landlords who house tenants outside city centres.
The supply picture
Build to Rent developments help increase housing supply, but they tend to be concentrated in city centres. In towns across the North and the Midlands, much of the rented housing is provided by individual landlords, often letting to families and tenants on lower incomes.
The consequence
This is why the pace of exit matters. If smaller landlords continue to leave faster than new homes are delivered, large-scale developments will not fill the gap, because they are rarely built in the towns where the loss is felt. Tenants will be left with less choice, reduced supply and higher rents.
Policymakers should be careful not to treat these landlords as interchangeable with institutional investors. They respond differently to risk, and they are the first to leave when rules become unpredictable, or costs mount. Keeping them in the sector is one of the most practical ways to protect the tenants the Act is designed to help.
Recovering a property: The courts must keep pace
Landlords need to know they can recover a property within a reasonable time when a tenant stops paying rent or causes serious problems. Without investment in the courts, that confidence will erode.
The Shift Since Section 21 With Section 21 abolished, every possession claim now has to be brought on a Section 8 ground and proved in court. Landlords issued 23,635 possession claims between April and June 2026, 6% more than in the same period of 2025, and Section 8 hearings are more complex than the accelerated route they replace.
Delays will grow unless the government invests properly in the court system and in bailiff enforcement. That will do more damage to investor confidence than any single policy discussed here.
Government position vs landlord experience
There is a clear gap between the government's confidence in the Act and landlords' experience of it. The government maintains that the courts have "sufficient capacity" to manage the impact of the Act, and it has announced the recruitment of 1,000 new judges and tribunal members. That is welcome, but those posts still have to be filled and make a difference on the ground. So far, landlords' experience since the Act came into force does not match the government's confidence.
The rising cost of being a landlord
Rent appeals, possession and the threat of rent control are compounded by taxes and rising regulatory obligations, which fall hardest on small landlords. On top of existing costs, landlords have to account for the PRS Database fee, licensing schemes, compliance costs and recent tax changes. Each of these may be manageable on its own, but together they can push small landlords out of the market completely.
Amending the Renters' Rights Act is not a step backwards for tenant security; it is a necessary measure to make the reforms work in practice. The government should revise the rent appeal rules, rule out rent controls, and properly fund the courts and bailiff enforcement. The wider property sector should support Prosper UK in calling for these changes to create a fairer, more effective and sustainable private rented sector.
Ultimately, without fair rent appeal rules, a functioning possession process and a more manageable regulatory and tax burden, more landlords will leave the sector. That means fewer rental homes, less choice for tenants and greater pressure on rents.


